168a22c71aeeb238c6378ecc1f02b1fe.jpeg

In Praise of Asymptotes

Not a Greek philosopher but a straight line which is continually approached by a given curve but does not meet it within a finite distance (OED); more generally, a boundary condition which cannot be attained regardless of the magnitude of the function; a process that’s never quite complete.

Asymptotic processes abound in real life:

Building: “is an asymptotic process,” a professor of Physics drily observed having gone through a two year conversion of a harbourside building to an almost completed habitable dwelling. A sentiment echoed daily around the world by frustrated building owners

Art: Impressionist paintings revised brush stroke by brush stroke. (And not so impressionist paintings too.) Canvases with themes painted over, sometimes hundreds of times. Peter Howson’s Prophecy is a modern example (This a long film and a subscription may be needed. A shorter timelapse is available).

Literature: Authors re-drafting, revising five, ten , fifteen times. Virginia Woolf took five years and countless re-drafts in writing The Voyage Out. Famous authors’ and poets’ notebooks are full of crossings out, revisions of key phrases, changings of words and word orders. Stories with unresolved endings, riddles, mysteries.

Music: Compositions or parts thereof which end with incomplete chords, leading notes or plain discords. Sections of Poulenc’s Gloria and a lot of more modern compositions such as minimalist works which never develop a theme (Glassworks by Philip Glass) and even Mozart’s Requiem which ends on an indeterminate chord which is neither major nor minor.

To which might be added Indexing:

Send a book to two experienced indexers and the results will differ; neither will be wrong; in fact both will be excellent; just different.

Why? Differing approaches, outlooks, appreciation of nuances, usage of idiom, ranges of knowledge. Human characteristics; all functions asymptotic to AI.

And there’s the inevitable time constraints under which indexes are crafted.

Review again after it has been finished and there’s always more. A better turn of phrase, a missed cross-reference possibility, an elective copy-editor’s change. Too late, the presses are running already. Mistakes? Not really, both indexes are fit for purpose well beyond mere adequacy.

Life is also asymptotic. But it is not a rehearsal. Nor can it be changed. ‘The moving finger writes; and, having writ, moves on…’

The message is that one must never stop; never stop working, communicating, loving, learning, querying, challenging the cortex of one’s soul. There’s always more to do, more to see, more to achieve. The asymptote is just over there…almost in sight.